Sotheby’s, auction, Toronto, 2 October 1974, lot 14 G.
Blair Laing Ltd., Toronto
Mr. & Mrs. Kenneth R. Thomson, Toronto
A.K. Prakash & Associates, Inc., Toronto
Masters Gallery, Calgary
Acquired by the present Private Collection, 2011
Exhibited
“Embracing Canada: Landscapes from Krieghoff to the Group of Seven”, Vancouver Art Gallery; travelling to the Glenbow Museum, Calgary; Art Gallery of Hamilton, 30 October 2015‒25 September 2016
“Canada and Impressionism: New Horizons 1880‒1930”, National Gallery of Canada, Ottawa; travelling to Kunsthalle der Hypo‒Kulturstiftung, Munich; Fondation de l’Hermitage, Lausanne; Musée Fabre, Montpellier, 19 July 2019‒3 July 2021, no. 60
Literature
Ian Thom, et al., “Embracing Canada: Landscapes from Krieghoff to the Group of Seven,” Vancouver/London, 2015, page 60, reproduced page 81
Katerina Atanassova, “Canada and Impressionism: New Horizons 1880‒1930”, Ottawa, 2019, no. 60, pages 253, 278 note 69, reproduced page 185
Born in Douglas, Ontario, Mary Bell studied at the Art Association of Montreal under Robert Harris, in New York at the Art Students League (circa 1885) under the impressionist William Merritt Chase, and in Paris, where she enrolled for a year in the early 1890s at the Académie Colarossi, a favourite destination for many North American art students. In 1897 she married the landscape painter Charles Eastlake, with whom she settled in England. She exhibited paintings, jewelry and enamelwork internationally, and even had a one-woman show at the Art Gallery of Toronto in 1927. She moved to Montreal with her husband at the start of the Second World War, and after his death returned to Almonte (Ontario), where she had spent much of her childhood.
Although not exclusively a figure painter, Bell Eastlake was best known for her depictions of girls and women in domesticated outdoor settings: subjects widely considered appropriate for women artists at the time. The girl and the baby in “In the Orchard” might be sisters, although their juxtaposition also underscored stereotypes about the natural evolution of girls into future mothers. Among Bell Eastlake’s contemporaries, artists such as Mary Cassatt, Helen McNicoll and Laura Muntz Lyall were also renowned for their views of young women, girls and babies. Indeed, as Katerina Atanassova has noted, the influence of Cassatt’s prints may be seen in the flatness and in the outlined forms of In the Orchard; Bell likely saw Cassatt’s prints when they were exhibited at the Galerie Durand‒Ruel in Paris in 1891.
Surveying Bell Eastlake’s career in 1925, “The Studio” described her work as “essentially decorative. She has a strong sense of rhythm and pattern. Her colour, which is pure and strong, is usually put down in flat tones, whether the medium be pastel, oil colour, or gouache. The characterisation of her portraits and figure subjects is excellent ... She excels in depicting babies and young children.” All of these qualities are present in In the Orchard, where the two figures are placed in a space whose shallowness is enhanced by the highly decorative fruit trees that both delimit the space and echo the decoratively curving elements of the cradle. By having the kneeling girl look straightforwardly at the spectator, Bell avoided the excessive sentimentality that often bedevilled paintings of children, while the warm colouring and dappled sunlight lend an immediacy that combines the freshness of Impressionism with a post-impressionist interest in outline and design. In the words of the art critic for journal “The Week”, writing in 1895 about another of Bell’s child-themed paintings (but with words that could as easily be applied to In the Orchard), the picture was “simply and solidly painted; a little piece of decoration which would give life and colour to a large space in many a drawing-room”.
Bell Eastlake only occasionally signed, and almost never dated, her canvases, but there are rare examples of comparable views of girls and young women in gardens that she signed with her married name (e.g., “Blue and Gold”; National Gallery of Canada). “In the Orchard” is signed “M.A. Bell”, and is therefore presumed to have been painted before her 1897 marriage, although as late as 1927 the Toronto Star noted that “Mrs. C.H. Eastlake ... is perhaps better known in Toronto as M.A. Bell.” Her work from earlier in the 1890s tended to be based on a more conservative palette, and it therefore seems reasonable to date “In the Orchard” to the middle years of the decade.
We extend our thanks to Brian Foss, Carleton University Chancellor’s Professor of Art & Architectural History, and co‒curator of “1920s Modernism in Montreal: The Beaver Hall Group” for his assistance in researching this artwork and for contributing the preceding essay.
